The Real Sailor-Kissing-Nurse Story: Kissing for Glory
It is often said that a photo is worth a thousand words. In still life, a memory is captured that creates history for generations and generations to come. The photographer is immortalised because of his acumen to capture the best moment while the subject of the photo gets recognition and celebrity status all over.
In the year 1945 on the day the Second World War came to an end, Alfred Eisenstaedt a renowned American photographer and photojournalist of that time, captured what would be regarded as one of the most awe-inspiring and iconic photographs of that era. Even six decades later, the photograph clicked does not fail to inspire the youth and displays to the world the meaning of the term jubilation and exhilaration.
Known as the V-J (Victory over Japan) Day Kiss, the captured photo of a sailor kissing a nurse in New York’s Times Square on the 14th August 1945, made waves all over the world as it got featured in the LIFE magazine edition published the following week.
The Story of the Kiss
Not all kisses are planned (some are, but we are not talking about them) and this was one of them. The sailor was rejoicing about the declaration of the Japanese surrender to the American forces and according to the memoirs stated by the photographer to a few magazines, was trying to kiss every woman on sight to display his exuberance about the win.
According to the photographer, the most important factor that made him capture this moment was due to the spontaneity in the way the nurse was snaffled and given a kiss, accounting for a worthy Kodak moment. The photojournalist, Alfred Eisenstaedt, also spoke about the contrast in the attire of the sailor kissing nurse that offered the photograph the clarity and resonance that enabled it to become such a popular figure.
The photograph displays the two subjects – the nurse kissing sailor – without displaying their actual identity. Alfred Eisenstaedt accounts this for the rapidity with which he had to click the photo without missing a moment of the actual kiss. This lack of clarity about the subjects’ identity, in the past couple of decades led to a massive search being carried out to find out who the sailor and the nurse were.
Ironically, all three parties in the picture – the sailor kissing nurse and the photographer himself did not have any personal details to pass on in case for any future encounters. The photographer was caught up in the spontaneity of the moment while both the subjects were too enraptured by the import of the clicking of their photo to think about the beyond.
Although the photo shows an unclear image about the subjects, it does full justice to the background of the impromptu osculation. The Times Square is prominently visible which in turn highlighted the kiss and the subjects even more.
Identifying the Subjects
A lot many men and women came forward declaring themselves to be the parties in the famous photo. But none were proved to be the protagonists in the photograph. Finally, towards the early 80s, a woman named Greta Friedman came forward and was found to be the nurse in the photographic documentary. However, even while her identity had been proved successfully, the photographer himself was unable to verify the claims of Ms. Friedman. She also denied participating in a reenactment of the image.
Greta Friedman who herself expired at the age of 92 in the year 2016, was 21 at the time when the photo was clicked.
As regards the male subject, three men professed to be the sailor in the picture and each was found to be very close to being the sailor. But after going through various polygraph tests and other tests to determine the authenticity of the three men – George Mendonca, Carl Muscarello and Glenn McDuffie – only McDuffie’s claims were found to be authentic and the identity of the kissing sailor and a nurse came to light.
Present Cult Happening
The sailor kisses nurse picture has a cult following all over the world. On the occasion of the V-J Day’s 60th anniversary as a part of the re-enactment of the happenings, a full-size statue in bronze was displayed in the Times Square. In the parade at the time of the re-enactment, Ms. Swain and Mr. Mendonca (at the time in contention to being the sailor) were participants though they did not re-enact the kiss to commemorate the occasion.
Photographic memories do not fade away. They are omnipresent and their omnipresence keeps one aware of their existence for time immemorial.
I loved this article. inspirational!
Glad you liked it!
Now this statue is in San Diego. It’s massive and such a great reminder of a respectable generation.
I have always loved this photo. I was born 16 years after this was taken, but, it still has an impact, for me. The unraveled mystery of who the sailor and nurse are, makes it no less cool. The impromptu kiss was such a wonderful way to show how happy people were, that the war was over. I am just surprised that there were not more people grabbing random others, to kiss. That was certainly the greatest reason to celebrate, on the streets of America! Thank you, Mr. Mendonsa and Ms. Friedman, for the beautiful moment, in history, that was before I was born!
I have always loved this photo, I am 15 and at school we are doing an assignment on famous.photographs that became a major part of history… My choice is very different to my class mates but I ceel this photo has a unique story.and this artical was a great help in my research
Yes indeed! The best part of this pic is the “moment” when it was captured.
It’s actually in the Aug 27th issue 1945. News didn’t travel so fast in those days!! lol
I have that issue!
Very cool story!
Loved the article. Very moving… My one comment is the last few paragraphs , it mentioned Glenn McDuffie being the authentic sailor, but at the end another was named, or did I misinterpret it wrong…