• Home
  • News
  • Videos
  • Marine Tech
    • Air Compressor
    • Ship Generator
    • Oily Water Separator
    • Ship Stabilizer
    • Boiler
  • Navigation
    • Mooring
    • Watchkeeping
    • Maneuvering
    • Anchoring
    • Equipment
  • Maritime Law
  • More
    • Case Studies
    • Life At Sea
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Marine Careers
    • Naval Arch
    • Ship Safety
    • Shipboard Guidelines
    • Forums
    • Types of Ships
    • Financial Planning
    • Photos
    • Apps
  • Premium E-Books
  • Free E-Books
  • Home
  • News
  • Videos
  • Marine Tech
    • Air Compressor
    • Ship Generator
    • Oily Water Separator
    • Ship Stabilizer
    • Boiler
  • Navigation
    • Mooring
    • Watchkeeping
    • Maneuvering
    • Anchoring
    • Equipment
  • Maritime Law
  • More
    • Case Studies
    • Life At Sea
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Marine Careers
    • Naval Arch
    • Ship Safety
    • Shipboard Guidelines
    • Forums
    • Types of Ships
    • Financial Planning
    • Photos
    • Apps
  • Premium E-Books
  • Free E-Books

Marine Insight

The Maritime Industry Guide

You are here: Home › Case Studies › Real Life Accident: Ship’s Chief Engineer Dies Due To Faulty Watertight Door

Real Life Accident: Ship’s Chief Engineer Dies Due To Faulty Watertight Door

By MARS Reports | In: Case Studies | Last Updated on October 2, 2020

TwitterFacebookLinkedInPinterestBuffer

While at berth, the crew of a small passenger ship were conducting a fire and emergency drill, which included closing and testing the hydraulically operated watertight doors. The Master closed the watertight doors remotely from the bridge.

Some minutes later, the chief engineer opened the watertight door to the engine room, but for some reason he became trapped by the door as he passed through the doorway. He remained trapped for more than eight minutes before being found and freed. He was resuscitated but never regained consciousness and later died in hospital. The door closing pressure was later measured to be 1,650 kg.

The watertight doors were normally set in the local-control mode, which meant that they could not be remotely closed from the wheelhouse. At the time of the accident the doors were in the remote-close mode for the exercise, which meant they would automatically close when the user released the opening handle.

watertight door

Image Credits: nautinst.org

 

The crew routinely passed through the watertight doors without fully opening them when the doors were in the local-control mode. This practice was probably also followed when the doors were in the remote-close mode. It is possible that the victim tried to pass through the door before it was fully open, and for some reason (such as releasing the handle) it began closing and trapped him.

The investigation found that, among other things:

  •  It was common practice on board not to fully open watertight doors before passing through. It is possible that the victim did not fully open the door on this occasion, which would have contributed to his becoming trapped.
  • The doors were set to close with a speed that was twice the maximum allowable under the SOLAS regulations (which specify never less than 20 seconds). This would likely have contributed to the victim becoming trapped.
  • The door operating handle protruded farther inside the watertight doorway space than was necessary. This meant the victim was not able to free himself when the door closed on him.
  • The watertight doors on board the vessel had not been maintained and tested in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions and did not meet the performance standards required by the IMO and the Flag State Administration.
  • The audible door closing alarm was not working after the accident. If it was not working at the time of the accident, that could have contributed to the victim becoming trapped in the door.
  • The safety management system on board the vessel did not deal in an appropriate way with the maintenance, testing and operation of the watertight doors, which were safety-critical apparatus that presented a known risk to the crew.

Lessons learned

  • Always fully open a watertight door before passing through the doorway when the door is in the remote-close mode.
  • The faster the door closes, the greater the risk.
  • Under no circumstances should watertight doors be set to close faster than the maximum allowable speed.
  • Ship operators should adopt specific procedures for operating watertight doors in both local-control and remote-close modes. The procedures should be compatible with the doors’ purpose and design, and the frequency with which they are used.
  • Legislation governing the design and use of watertight doors should be flexible enough to achieve appropriate procedures for the use of any watertight door in any mode.
  • Poorly maintained watertight doors are dangerous. Shipboard planned maintenance systems should be designed and followed to ensure that watertight doors are maintained in accordance with manufacturers’ instructions, and in accordance with good standard marine engineering practice.

Reference: nautinst

Report an Error

Related Posts

Turkish ship fire
Turkish Seafarer Passes Away Due To Fire On Bridge Of Cargo Ship
open hold
Real Life Incident: Crewmember’s Fatal Fall Into A Hold
Ava Claire under way before the casualty.
Case Study: Captain’s Sleep Inertia Led To Tow Striking Lock Gate
ampar 8 tanker
Crude Oil Being Unloaded From Tanker Ship That Exploded In Thailand

Tags: accident Fatal Accident real life incident

Want to share your tips and advice? Got questions? Visit the community forum to ask questions, get answers, meet people, and share your tips!

About MARS Reports

The Mariners' Alerting and Reporting Scheme is primarily a confidential reporting system run by The Nautical Institute to allow full reporting of accidents (and near misses) without fear of identification or litigation. MARS reports also regularly comprise alerts condensed from official industry sources, so that issues resulting from recent incidents can be efficiently relayed to the mariner on board.

Comments

  1. Pam Lassila says

    March 1, 2017 at 6:55 pm

    I didn’t know how important watertight hatches could be! That is really sad that he passed away that way. I guess we can learn from this that they are very important.

  2. ISMAIL says

    February 10, 2019 at 8:35 pm

    Really sad. Senior officer should be more careful on safety matter.

  3. jojo says

    February 11, 2019 at 3:36 am

    notice has been posted in the watertight door itself ” informing the crew not to pass to the moving WTD as far as i know” as per regulation the doors closing time is not more than 1min in upright position.
    this is a matter of how the crew members undetrstand the safety onboard and how they are cautious.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Now

road in pacific ocean brighter

Watch: Mysterious “Yellow Brick Road” Discovered In The Pacific Ocean

NYK's First Chief Engineers Successfully Complete NTMA And Internal Training Program

NYK’s First Chief Engineers Successfully Complete NTMA And Internal Training Program

Top 10 most powerful tugboats in the world

Top 10 Most Powerful Tugboats in the World

Turkish ship fire

Turkish Seafarer Passes Away Due To Fire On Bridge Of Cargo Ship

carolina lady / catherine lady

Captain Leaving Wheelhouse While On Autopilot Led To Grounding Of Fishing Vessel

Marine Engineering

  • Marine engine
  • Air compressor
  • Marine boiler
  • Oily water separator
  • Marine Electrical
  • Ship Generator
  • Oily water separator

Nautical Science

  • Mooring
  • Bridge Watchkeeping
  • Ship Manoeuvring
  • Nautical Charts
  • Anchoring
  • Nautical Equipment
  • Shipboard Guidelines

Explore

  • Free Maritime eBooks
  • Premium Maritime eBooks
  • Marine Safety
  • Financial Planning
  • Marine Careers
  • Maritime Law
  • Ship Dry Dock

More

  • Shipping News
  • Maritime Reports
  • Videos
  • Maritime Piracy
  • Offshore
  • Safety Of Life At Sea (SOLAS)
  • MARPOL
  Privacy Policy   |   Refund Policy   |   Contact Us  |   Disclaimer   |   About Us   |   Team   |   Advertise  |   Send Us News

Copyright © 2010 - 2022 Marine Insight — All Rights Reserved | Made with ♥ in India DMCA.com Protection Status

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website