Real Life Accident: Ship’s OS Loses Life While Rigging Pilot Ladder

The deck crew were preparing the starboard pilot boarding ladder in combination with the accommodation ladder due to the freeboard of 10.2 metres.

Strong winds were blowing so the deck crew put their safety helmets away. They started to pay out and secure the pilot ladder to a height of one and a half metres above the water. After the pilot ladder was secured the crew lowered the accommodation ladder to about five metres below the main deck.

An experienced ordinary seaman (OS) then went down the accommodation ladder in order to set the railings and the lower platform. He was wearing an inflatable life jacket (manual release) and had secured himself on a lifeline with safety harness. The pilot embarkation station was properly illuminated.

Pilot boarding a ship from a pilot boat, prior to entering a harbour (Image credits : Danny Cornelissen)
Representation Image – credits : Danny Cornelissen

At one point, the crew on deck realised something was wrong; they then saw the victim lying in the water still attached to the lifeline and obviously unconscious. The bridge was informed and a life buoy with safety line was thrown into the water. First attempts to pull the OS out of the water were unsuccessful due to the headway of the vessel and the soaked winter clothes of the victim. Only after more crew arrived on scene was it possible to pull him out of the water a few metres and, after about 10 minutes, the victim was retrieved on board. Despite immediate artificial respiration and heart massage the victim passed away.

Lessons learned:
– The length of the lifeline was about 9.75 metres. During the accident the platform was only about five metres below the main deck; this allowed a free fall of more than four metres.
– None of the deck crew assisting had seen the OS fall as they were attending to other duties. Best practices require constant surveillance of a person working over the side on a vessel underway.
– The victim sustained head injuries and became unconscious after the fall, which hindered his rescue and survival. A helmet with chin strap could have prevented the head injuries.
– The heavy weather conditions and the fact that the combination ladder was on the windward side of the vessel increased risk for this operation. Yet, the company permit to work on deck in heavy weather states that the operation should be aborted if crew are at risk.
– Course and speed alterations may have been possible to mitigate the weather influences at the ship’s starboard side.

Editor’s note: Helmets worn with chin straps should be the norm. In this case, not only were the crew not wearing chin straps, but due to the strong winds they actually took off and stowed their safety helmets.

Do you have info to share with us ? Suggest a correction

Article Footer Banner
Article Footer Banner

Web Stories

Subscribe To Our Newsletters

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and may receive occasional deal communications; you can unsubscribe anytime.

5 Comments

  1. Helmet chin straps should be worn in bad weather conditions and the operation should have been overseen at all times there is a man over the side rigging a pilot’s ladder or any other task involving having a man over the side. Work orders are useless unless the risk assessments are followed and implemented in a professional manner. Familiarity breeds contempt, a very sad loss and a hard lesson learned. RIP.

    C.E.

  2. why the os ( ordinary seaman ) w/c has less experience to do the job where is the bosun why he allowed the o/s to do the job ……. no risk assessment ….

  3. First of all, my condoleance to the family of the poor guy falling overboard. Every accident is one too many. Unfortunately this accident perfectly shows the mentality of the industry.

    The whole article seems to focus on a helmet. A helmet (with or without chin strap) could not prevent someone drowning while being dragged through the water on a lifeline for 10 minutes.. This industry has to stop saying that “safety” equals “helmet” and start thinking about what could work in different situations. In this particular case it is clear that a shorter lifeline could have saved this person’s life (not a helmet or lifejacket). The crew taking off their helmets is proper seamanship as helmets can only fall overboard and hit the guy working on the gangway, they have NO more added value while working on deck at sea then when working at home in the kitchen and I doubt any of you wears a helmet when BBBQing with the family.

    Also, it seems the author thinks that throwing a lifebuoy at an unconsious person attached to a lifeline is good practice, please think about that for a second. I believe this whole situation and especially the response of the crew is a good example for the state of the maritime industry. Don’t think, follow procedure..

  4. Condolence to the bereaved family. It also happen to my friend in ship yesteryears ago. He also had no look out whilst working. ALONE. Management level officers need not to let their colleagues work alone. Just in order to maximise the time co complete their assign responsibilities.
    C/E LE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *